By Rick Noack
One day after the fall of the
Berlin Wall, on Nov. 9, 1989, former West German chancellor Willy Brandt said:
"Now what belongs together will grow together." With the opening of
the border, communism in East Germany was doomed. But has Germany grown
together, as Brandt predicted?
Last week, WorldViews explained
how eastern and western Germany are still divided in some ways.
But there are also lessons to
be learned from Germany unification. Here are four -- proposed by Germans from
both sides of the now-destroyed Berlin Wall.
A divided country needs a joint
mission
The environment has always been
a crucial issue in German politics. When the Ukrainian nuclear power plant
Chernobyl caused fear and panic throughout Europe after its meltdown in 1986,
the Berlin Wall was still standing. Soon after, a united Germany evolved as a
world leader both in climate politics as well as in the development of
technological solutions.
After the 2011 nuclear disaster
in Fukushima, Japan, German Chancellor Angela Merkel -- born in the east --
reversed her previous stance and announced a surprising and possibly
groundbreaking goal: Germany would strive to become the first industrialized
country to abolish both coal and nuclear power as energy sources. Renewable
energy sources are to fill the void. Succeeding would likely be impossible if
reunification had not happened. The east -- highly dependent on coal in
communist times -- now produces 30 percent of its electricity using renewable
energy, one-third more than western Germany does.
Wolfgang Gründinger, born in
Germany's southern state of Bavaria, is the spokesperson for the Foundation for
the Rights of Future Generations. This year, Germany for the first time
generated more energy from renewables than any other source, including coal and
nuclear power plants. The project is expensive, which has increased electricity
prices, particularly in the east. Despite that, Gründinger considers the rise
of renewable energy projects the country's first successful joint east-west
project:
No matter whether one is east
or west German, the overwhelming majority of us share the opinion that we need
to transform our energy supplies from fossil and nuclear to renewable and
sustainable sources to stop climate change and prevent a nuclear catastrophe.
In East Germany, renewable
energies not only created jobs and economic perspectives in otherwise
underdeveloped regions, but – and probably more important – restored the
tarnished self-confidence of the east Germans.
It only takes one generation to
change attitudes and prejudices
Some argue that Germany's
success in renewable energy is tightly connected to a new generation that does
not care about the east-west prejudices of their parents anymore. Mike Goller
was 16 years old when the Berlin Wall came down -- and before, he had never
really thought about East Germany. The neighboring country seemed too distant.
One month after the wall fell, he crossed the border to the GDR (the official
abbreviation for East Germany) for the first time.
I do not ask myself whether
German reunification was a success. It had to happen, and opening the borders
of an imprisoned society is a success in itself.
Furthermore, we should not
always ask the question: What went wrong? German reunification could have gone
so much worse. Traditional and economic changes are slow, but if you look at
the new generation you will see much less of a divide. Some differences
prevail, but they matter much less to those who grew up in a united Germany.
Goller recently worked on a
multimedia project called "Germany 25" that features 25 young Germans
and what they think about their country. The majority of them consider the
country's north and south to be further apart than east and west, according to
another, more representative study. Their parents, however, are much less
progressive: Many of them would not agree with their children, according to
sociologist Andreas Zick, who has studied the different attitudes for years.
Integrating foreigners is important (and
eastern Germany would be better off it it had)
Karamba Diaby is worried about
another aspect: the conversation around the 25th anniversary of the fall of the
Berlin Wall. He arrived in then-East Germany in 1985 as an immigrant from
Senegal. Back then, he knew little about the communist country that would cease
to exist only four years later.
Today, he represents his home
state, Saxony Anhalt, as a member of Germany's national parliament. When he was
elected last year, his success made national headlines: Diaby is the country's
first black member of parliament ever.
One aspect has been largely
ignored in Germany: the lives of immigrants in the east. Many people came here
from other communist countries such as Angola, Algeria, Cuba -- but their fate
has largely been forgotten. Some of them returned; others stayed here. Their
immigration, however, still needs to be facilitated. Many rural eastern German
areas would hugely benefit economically if more foreigners lived there.
To Diaby, there can only be one
solution: "Bring people in touch with each other," he says. This
might seem an obvious idea, but it's not to many eastern Germans. Only 36
percent of eastern Germans said in a recent survey that they were interacting
with foreigners in their daily lives, compared to 75 percent in western
Germany.
Unification can lead to
prosperity
Manouchehr Shamsrizi, a
26-year-old Yale Global Justice Fellow, is among the most publicly prominent
voices of Germany's younger generation as an adviser to the World Economic
Forum's Global Shapers Community. According to him, German reunification bears
many similarities with the emergence of the European Union.
Those of my friends who
traveled a lot and visited other parts of the world really believe that a
united Germany must logically aim for becoming part of the "United States
of Europe" -- something one can be proud of as a progressive and
value-based democratic union, rather than an estranged technocratic government
somewhere in Brussels. Europe and other parts of the world could learn a lot
from Germany.
East Germany is still lagging
behind, but there has been lots of progress -- not only economically -- if you
consider that in some German cities, about 96 percent of industrial jobs
disappeared within only half a year after Germany unified. The cost of
unification was high in the short run, but even if you solely look at it
economically, the benefits will largely outweigh the disadvantages in the
future. Already today, many cities in east Germany, like Leipzig or Berlin, are
seen as international hotspots for entrepreneurship.
Could the reunification of
Germany be a role model for Europe, economically as well as politically? Yes, I
think so.
Комментариев нет:
Отправить комментарий